Russia blocks agenda at UN lethal autonomous weapons conference

Photo: Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA)

The Chronify

Share:

By International Desk

A United Nations conference on lethal autonomous weapons systems stalled on Nov 16 after Russia raised procedural objections regarding observers, preventing the adoption of an agenda. UN chief Antonio Guterres appealed for strict and binding rules to govern military artificial intelligence.

A United Nations conference focused on lethal autonomous weapons systems stalled on Nov 16 as procedural objections from Russia blocked the adoption of an agenda. Representatives from the 128 countries that are parties to the convention gathered in Geneva to determine whether to launch negotiations towards regulating the use of such weapons.

The meeting opened with a video message from UN chief Antonio Guterres, who appealed for countries to work towards imposing strict and binding rules on lethal autonomous weapons systems. Guterres called on delegates to prevent the use and spread of these weapons and to move towards negotiating a legally binding instrument that includes clear prohibitions and restrictions.

Warfare is undergoing a radical transformation as armies seek to capitalise on artificial intelligence to boost their fighting abilities by identifying and striking targets more quickly and with greater accuracy. Amid a chorus of warnings against handing the power of life and death to autonomous machines, delegates arrived in Geneva to decide whether to start formal talks.

The NGO Human Rights Watch told the conference that a failure to act would leave civilians dangerously exposed. Others have warned of the severe dangers if lethal autonomous weapons systems are permitted to select and kill targets without human intervention.

Proceedings ground to a halt before noon when Russia triggered a procedural stand-off by objecting to allowing observers, including the European Union and civil society organisations, to participate in the debate. This move immediately blocked the adoption of an agenda for the talks.

Conference president Julien Thoni, of Switzerland, ordered informal consultations in an effort to resolve the deadlock after the initial objection prevented the conference from getting started. Discussions had always been expected to be challenging, with countries at odds and full consensus needed for any decisions.

Six hours later, Thoni stated that he was still seeking a solution to the procedural impasse and announced that closed-door informal discussions would continue on Nov 17. Meanwhile, the representative for Moscow told the conference that delegates could count on the full, positive and constructive support of the Russian Federation.

Campaigners suggested that the move by Moscow was an attempt to dodge criticism regarding its own alleged use of such weapons in its war in Ukraine. Anna Hehir, head of military AI governance at the Future of Life Institute, insisted that states must ensure that Russia, or any of the governments blocking progress, are not allowed to hold the future hostage.

While many states are in favour of tighter rules, countries that possess the technology, including the United States and Russia, remain reluctant to have their hands tied. The International Committee of the Red Cross is calling for a ban on two categories of autonomous weapons: unpredictable autonomous weapons and those designed or used to directly target humans.

ICRC president Mirjana Spoljaric stated ahead of the conference that states have a crucial responsibility to ensure that the future of warfare is not handed over to machines, adding that future generations will judge whether leaders acted to prevent a world where machines autonomously kill humans.

At the UN General Assembly in New York in October, 163 states adopted a resolution calling for negotiations on rules governing autonomous weapons. Five countries voted against the resolution: the United States, Russia, Belarus, Israel and North Korea, which recently boasted of a new AI-enabled torpedo system.

Nine states abstained on the October UN General Assembly resolution, including Iran, Saudi Arabia and China. Laure de Roucy-Rochegonde of the French Institute of International Relations noted that China has maintained a carefully cultivated ambiguity on the issue.

Washington has proposed a five-year process to develop a non-binding instrument to address military artificial intelligence. In contrast, NGOs and the International Committee of the Red Cross are advocating for a much faster one-year timeline towards binding rules.

Elected News

Top Read News